Skip to main content

Pricing: Discounting v. Unbundling

With times being so tough, most companies feel that the only way to attract new customers is to lower their pricing. While doing so in some cases will generate a short burst of activity and increased revenues, as a standard, long term course of action, it is not a wise thing to do .

The first reason why it is not a good idea to lower your prices is that your associated costs have not been lowered, and in order to make the same amount of profit, you have to sell a higher percentage of product just to stay even. A case in point, if you lower your prices by 20%, you need to increase your sales volume by 25%. If you reduce your prices by 30%, then you need a correspondent increase in sales VOLUME of 42%; a 40% discount needs a 67% increase in sales. I think you see where this is going. Unless there is a huge amount of elasticity in your pricing (where volume increases appreciably more with a price reduction), that without corresponding lowering of your costs, a reduction in price is at best a stop gap measure and at worst can lead to your eventual demise.

There are also some secondary problems that arise when you just arbitrary lower prices without taking something away in the sale. While market conditions might warrant some course of drastic action, an arbitrary price reduction can accidentally convey two things to your present and future customers. The first is an ongoing expectation that you will always lower your prices when things are tough. This essentially conditions your customers to "wait it out" until you decide to lower prices. The second is an impression that you have been lying to them all along if all of a sudden you can lower you price without giving up anything in exchange. This second situation is disastrous to the long term health of your company.

So what are you to do to increase sales AND profits? If you have to lower your prices, there are some strategies you can use to add more customers, reduce your costs, stay above the fray, and in the process keep from loosing the farm.

First and foremost, you need to look at how much PROFIT you make pre product and which products produce the most profits, not necessarily the most revenues. If you can make $10 selling a $20 item, or $20 selling a $100 item, sell the hell out of the $20 item. Plus the margin on the $20 item is 50% (versus 20%), and it will be a hell of a lot easier to sell five $20 items, than one $100 item (usually). Next, look at your portfolio of products and get rid (i.e. stop selling) those products that do NOT generate significant PROFITS. That is right! You may have to shelve high volume revenue products that are NOT producing profits. THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT CONCEPT I CAN CONVEY TO YOU, and it will be a hard pill to swallow in some case, but in the long run the you will see the benefits of actually having MORE money and will have to exert LESS effort in obtaining it by following this strategy.

OK, say all your products make about the same profits, and they are all priced comparably, what then? The next strategy is called unbundling. Say you have a product you sell for $100, and it has 3 or 4 components to it. Well, you can now remove sell each component separately for say $40 (versus $25 in a bundle), OK, say you cannot physically separate the product what then? Well you can ask the customer to give up (or pay extra for) the warranty, or customer service, or something if you are going to sell it for anything close to $25. This does two things: First is to increase your profits (or reduce your costs) and secondly instill some value for the “freebies” you used to give away while giving your customers the power to choose what “features” they want to pay (or save on) for.

A good example unbundling comes from Proctor & Gamble's attempt to sell shampoo into India. Initially, P&G wanted to sell a 12 oz container of its shampoo into the Indian market (similar to how they sell in Europe and the USA. There initial foray was disastrous for two reasons. First, this container cost the equivalent of a day's salary and secondly since Indians do not wash their hair as often as in the West, the quantity was equivalent to a year's worth of shampoo. P&G was able to penetrate this market (and still holds an 80% market share) when repacked their product for a single use size (about 20 rupees or 40 cents). This move was actually MORE profitable for P&G than selling in volume and allowed them to services a market that was previously untapped.

Too often I just see people leave money on the table when price negotiations begin and end. With these strategies and focusing on your profits (instead of just revenues), you will be in a better position to weather this economic storm of uncertainty.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Moldy Middle

While taking statistics during my quest to get an MBA and while earning my engineering degree, the professors always emphasized the importance of finding the statistical mean of any population by using the Central Mean Theorem (a.k.a the highest point of the Bell Curve). As an engineer, this was essential in order to maximize throughput, minimize cost and waste, and ultimately make a better, faster, cheaper widget. A funny thing happened on the way to the dark side of marketing. I discovered that the only thing in the middle of the road was quite literally dead road kill. I do not know if you remember stores like Bradlees, Ames and Service Merchandise (just to name a few), but they all folded because the environment changed and they were caught trying to service the mythological “average customer.” Part of that change came when Wal-Mart began its juggernaut with the discount department store. Wal-Mart did two things right: 1) Focused on “mobile” consumers, and 2) Fo...

Fortune Cookie of Persistence

There are many things or factors that can determine a person’s success or failure, but one thing that cuts across EVERY successful person I have met or read about or studied is perseverance, persistence, stick-to-itiveness, and determination. As I say, "Nothing in the world can take the place of persistence. The desire and ability to press on has and always will solve the problems of the human race and divide those who achieve from those who might have been." Incredibly, this ONE characteristic is really what makes a true entrepreneur as testimony to these little factoids: Coca-Cola only sold twenty five (25) bottles in its first year of business! They grossed $50.0 and spent $73.96 on merchandising. But they kept on going and never gave up, and nowadays the sell more than one billion bottles per day! Apple Computer co-founder offered the computer design to Hewlett-Packard five times and was rejected by both HP and Atari (the giant at the time) for acquisition. A...

Chance and the Cosmos

What if we are alone?  With the recent breathtaking Venus in Transit pictures happening yesterday, I was amazed at the size and scope of this cosmic happening. What struck me was how everyone was talking about how rare an event this was, and it got me thinking about space, and probabilities, and are we alone? I remember as a kid hearing Carl Sagan talk about the billion upon billion of stars in the universe and the probability that somewhere out there, there has to be life around one of those other stars. According to the European Space Agency’s scientists, there are 1 times 10 to the 12 (a 1 with 12 zeros trailing) stars in our galaxy, and perhaps 1 times 10 to the 11 or 12 galaxies in the universe.  That means there are 1 times 10 to the 23 or 24 (1 with 24 zeros trailing) stars in our universe. That is a vast amount of places that could have a planet like ours.  But now we have to think small, like in chance and probabilities, and this got me postulating. Ea...